Collectives™ on Stack Overflow

Find centralized, trusted content and collaborate around the technologies you use most.

Learn more about Collectives

Teams

Q&A for work

Connect and share knowledge within a single location that is structured and easy to search.

Learn more about Teams

Please explain to me why the following piece of code complies and works perfectly. I am very confused.

#include<iostream>
template<class A = int, class B=double>
class Base
template<class B>
class Base <int, B>
public:
  Base()
     std::cout<<"it works!!!!!\n";
int main()
  Base<> base; // it prints "it works!!!!!"
  return 0;

Shouldn't it fall into the generalized form of the template class Base?

I agree. An excellent question and (particularly), a superb job of asking it, complete with SSCCE and good description of both actual and expected behavior. Well done! – Jerry Coffin Sep 9, 2013 at 15:10

The default argument applies to the specialization -- and, in fact, a specialization must accept (so to speak) the base template's default argument(s). Attempting to specify a default in the specialization:

template<class A = int, class B=double>
class Base
template<class B=char>
// ...

...is an error.

Likewise, if we change the specialization so that its specialization is for a type other than the default provided by the base template:

template<class A = int, class B=double>
class Base
template<class B>
class Base <char, B>

...then the base template will be chosen.

So, what's happening is this: first the types for the template arguments are chosen. In this case (no type specified at instantiation), both types are based on the default template arguments specified in the base template.

Then (as a basically separate step) it carries out an analog of overload resolution on all templates that fit those argument types. As usual for overload resolution, a type that's specified explicitly is preferred over one that's specified implicitly, so your specialization (which specified int explicitly) is preferred over the base template (which specified int implicitly).

Jerry, for your information, I posted a question which relates to a statement you make here: "if we change the specialization so that its specialization is for a type other than the default provided by the base template then the base template will be chosen": stackoverflow.com/questions/52583833/… – Fabio Oct 1, 2018 at 2:58

Here the default values/initialization for A and B have been declared respectively as int and double.

 template<class B>
 class Base <int, B>

Here in class definitions, the first argument is something like a constant value(here int; why declare this way just making things complex? Better remove the first template argument) and the second template argument is B who default value is 'double'.

Base<> base;

When you create the object of the class. Although you do not specify the template arguments, the compiler takes default values of the arguments(A and B)which are 'int' and 'double' and the code executes without any errors or warnings. See what happens when you create the object as:
Base<float,char> b; or Base<char,char> b;

I believe the question is: why is the partial specialization chosen rather than the primary template in this case. I don't see this addressed in your answer. – Mat Sep 9, 2013 at 15:03

When you write Base<> base; the compiler will try to find out if instantiation of Base<> class is possible or not if it is possible the code would work fine. In this case it is possible due to the default template argument of Base because the compiler knows if you if you write Base<> it needs to create a object of Base<int,double>. i.e: because of:

template<class A = int, class B=double>
class Base

So the code works fine.

Thanks for contributing an answer to Stack Overflow!

  • Please be sure to answer the question. Provide details and share your research!

But avoid

  • Asking for help, clarification, or responding to other answers.
  • Making statements based on opinion; back them up with references or personal experience.

To learn more, see our tips on writing great answers.